AFL Rankings: Round 14 2020

 Melbourne has powered into finals contention on the back of its ‘fab four’.

The Demons are one of the better teams again

After an excellent 2018, and a disappointing 2019, it was hard to know what to expect from Melbourne this season. The Demons did not start off the season in sparkling form; they lost a close match to Geelong, but otherwise were not overly impressive in their first five matches. The first hint that they may have turned a bit of a corner was their seven-goal demolition of Hawthorn, where their stars (more on them below) went berserk.

In recent weeks, Melbourne has shown some more of that form, and the form that got them into the finals two season ago. They had three successive wins by more than 50 points, which is pretty impressive even when you consider the quality of their opposition (see chart above) – though Collingwood are no easybeats. 

Last week’s loss against the Bulldogs had many questioning whether it was yet another false dawn, but this week’s close win against fellow finals aspirant St. Kilda may have some Demons’ fans believing again. Only the red-hot Geelong Cats have bettered Melbourne’s average adjusted net margin of +27 points over their past five matches.

As much as I sometimes wish to highlight particular players on this blog, generally the contribution of a team’s players in Australian football is fairly even, and a team’s performance is more reliant on the quality of twenty players rather than just a few. Melbourne’s playing list however, is more lop-sided than most.

Big Maxy, Clarry, Trac, and Viney

As of the end of Round 14, Melbourne has four of the top twenty-five players on the AFL’s Player Ratings for the season: ruck Max Gawn, and midfielders Clayton Oliver, Christian Petracca (the #1 player), and Jack Viney.  

While the Player Ratings sometimes is subject to raised eyebrows – such as this week when GWS forward Jake Riccardi kicked four goals and was rated the worst player on the ground – it is fairly easy to demonstrate the value of these players using less advanced measures.

Max Gawn, as is well-known, is one of the most effective rucks in the game. Currently in season 2020 he ranks second for hit outs per game, behind Brodie Grundy. Another part of what makes him really valuable though is his marking around the ground – he ranks seventh for contested marks per game in 2020, well ahead of many other top ruckman (see table below).

Meanwhile, Oliver, Petracca and Viney – as the AFL Player Ratings suggest – are possibly the most effective ‘inside’ midfield trio in the game. (Though Dogs fans will note their star midfield beat them handily last week.) All rank within the top twenty for contested possessions per game, with Oliver (#2) and Petracca (#4) sitting in the top five (see table below). No other team has three of the top 20. Oliver and Viney also rank in the top twenty for clearances per game. All three rank in the top 50 for metres gained per game, with Oliver kicking the ball more this season. Petracca, while not ranking as high for clearances, has continued to be an attacking weapon and ranks second for score involvements.

Will it be enough though to get the Demons into the finals? There’s still eighteen other players in the team who will determine Melbourne’s fate. The recent good form of defenders Steven May and Jake Lever helped get the Demons across the line on the weekend. If they can continue to support their star midfield, then Melbourne could cause some trouble this Septem - … er, October.